In the 1730’s, English, German and Scots-Irish immigrants settled in the area of South Central Pennsylvania known as Cumberland County, devoting their lives to farming the rich soil of the region. The Widow Piper’s Tavern, in Shippensburg, was originally used as the courthouse until the Cumberland County Courthouse was built and the county seat established in Carlisle. Named for Cumberland, England, Cumberland County was officially founded on January 27, 1750.
Widow Piper's Tavern
Painting of Carlisle square
Plans for street layout of Carlisle
Town hall Line drawing
For decades, the sweet sound of the courthouse bell rang out clearly; proclaiming civil, legal, and religious events, as well as emergencies. Then, on March 24, 1845, soon after 1 a.m., the bell sounded its last note. The town hall, with all its equipment still inside, was engulfed in flames. Strong winds carried the blaze to the courthouse rooftop, and although townspeople were able to save the records stored within, the fire spread rapidly, destroying the entire building, including the bell. By 4 a.m. all that remained of the courthouse lie in a pile of smoldering ashes.
The courthouse and town hall as they existed before the fire
Newspaper article announcing the fire
Remains of the original bell recovered after the fire
A bill to restore the gold leaf on the dial of the town clock
Front facing plans for the restored courthouse, proposed in 1845
The original courthouse, completed in 1766, was rebuilt after the fire of March 24, 1845
A present-day view of the historic courthouse
The main courthouse was constructed in 1962. It houses the County Commissioners, Row Offices, and the Courts.
In 1753 Benjamin Franklin successfully negotiated an Indian treaty with several tribes in Carlisle, and the Carlisle Barracks was established in 1757. It is the second oldest military post in the United States and is currently home to the U.S. Army War College. George Washington used Carlisle in 1794 as the site to muster troops for a march to western Pennsylvania, as he attempted to quell the Whiskey Rebellion. Revolutionary War Generals William Thompson, William Irving, and John Armstrong called Cumberland County their home, and the legendary Revolutionary War heroine Mary Hays, better known as Molly Pitcher, lived, and is buried in Carlisle.
It was determined the fire was the work of an arson, and a reward of $5,000 was offered for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the criminal. Although the incident was brought to the Grand Jury on April 17, 1845, no evidence was ever brought forth which would lead to a perpetrator. Soon after the blaze, bids were proposed, and plans for a new courthouse were approved by the Commissioners. Daniel E. Wilt and Samuel Bryan completed the work by 1846, at an estimated cost of $49,000. Our stately Georgian style courthouse stands today, a symbol of Cumberland County’s historic beauty.
Historic Courthouse clocktower door
Molly Pitcher carried water to the soldiers at the Battle of Monmouth in 1778.
Molly Pitcher's grave is located in the Old Graveyard in Carlisle
The Underground Railroad extended through Cumberland County
Underground RR sites throughout the county
Residents took great risks to help free runaway slaves
Rewards were offered for the return of runaway slaves
Pennsylvania passed an Act to gradually abolish slavery on March 1, 1780, making it one of the first states to take steps towards abolition. However, slavery continued in Cumberland County until 1847, an additional 67 years. The Underground Railroad extended through Cumberland County, utilizing two main routes for fugitive slaves. One route passed through Pine Grove, Mt. Holly Springs, Boiling Springs, Mechanicsburg, and Harrisburg, before heading north. The second route followed Walnut Bottom and Old York Roads, before entering Boiling Springs and continuing to Harrisburg.
J.E.B. Stuart and Fitzhugh Lee were stationed at the Carlisle Barracks during the time it was a Cavalry Post. Later, in June 1863, as Confederate Generals of the Civil War, they ordered their troops to burn the Barracks on their way to Gettysburg. The Carlisle Barracks became the site of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in 1879. It housed and educated approximately 11,000 Native Americans until its closure in 1918. Jim Thorpe was one of its notable students. The famed athlete won gold medals in the 1912 Summer Olympic Games in Stockholm, Sweden.
Today, along with our rich farmland, our county landscape is comprised of urban communities spanning 555 square miles, with more than 270,000 residents living in 33 municipalities.
Farming remains a vital part of Cumberland County
The rich farmland of Cumberland County
There are 33 municipalities in Cumberland County
The main courthouse, constructed in 1962, currently houses the County Commissioners, Row Offices, and Courts.
Cumberland County communities are rich in history
Many families came from Europe and settled in the area devoting their lives to farming the rich soils of the county.
For more information and to find things to do in Cumberland County visit